Cardano founder Charles Hoskinson accused Vitalik Buterin of overstating cryptography threats and said his recommendations could harm internet security, outlining his position in a post.
Lattice-based cryptography has been studied for over 40 years
According to Hoskinson, lattice-based mathematical approaches have been researched for more than 40 years, during which many potential attacks have been identified and are already considered in the design of modern security algorithms.
Criticism of hash functions and the idea to increase key sizes tenfold
He recalled that hash functions are also vulnerable: MD5 and SHA-1 have been broken, and the Poseidon hash used in the Ethereum ecosystem, in his view, has a mathematical structure that could be targeted by new attacks. Hoskinson called the proposal to increase key sizes by a factor of ten "numerology" without scientific basis.
ML-KEM and the risk of slowing the post-quantum transition
Hoskinson believes that doubts about ML-KEM and other advice from Buterin could slow the adoption of post-quantum protection. In his view, this could keep browsers, VPNs, and messengers reliant on cryptography vulnerable to quantum computers.
AI does not replace a threat model and examples of past reversals
He does not consider the forecast that AI will achieve 50 years of mathematical breakthroughs in two years to be a threat model, noting the lack of specific attack algorithms and cost assessments. Hoskinson also stated that Buterin's publications have previously led engineers to abandon important research, only to revisit it later, citing Plasma, Ethereum 2.0, and Casper as examples.
